DBQ SCORING RUBRIC
|
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
TASK |
Minimally develops some aspects of the task |
Minimally develops task or some of the task in depth |
Develops all / most aspects of task w/ little depth |
Develops all aspects of task but may be uneven |
Thoroughly develops all aspects of task evenly |
ANALYSIS |
Descriptive, lacks understanding |
Descriptive or faulty/weak |
More descriptive than analytical |
Descriptive and analytical |
Is more analytical than descriptive |
USE OF DOCUMENTS |
Vague, unclear reference to docs, irrelevant info copied from documents |
Limited use of documents, info copied directly from documents |
Incorporates some relevant info from at least half the documents |
Incorporates relevant info from at least 1 more than half the documents |
Incorporates relevant info from at least 1 more than half the documents |
OUTSIDE INFORMATION |
No relevant outside information |
Presents little or no relevant outside information |
Uses limited outside information |
Uses some relevant outside information |
Substantial outside information is used |
ACCURACY |
Few relevant facts, may include inaccuracies |
Few relevant facts, may include minor inaccuracies |
Some relevant facts, may include minor inaccuracies |
Supports theme with relevant facts, examples, etc. |
Richly supports theme with relevant facts, examples, etc. |
ORGANIZATION |
Weak, lacks focus, contains digressions, lacks intro/conclusion, unclear addressing of task |
General plan, lacks focus, contains digressions, lacks introduction or conclusion |
Satisfactory plan of organization; intro and conclusion are restatements of the theme |
Logical and clear plan of organization beyond restatement of theme |
Logical and clear plan of organization beyond restatement of theme |